Digital Ash in a Digital Urn
Is the attention warranted? Not yet. But pop culture doesn't wait for promising artists to mature before showering them with hype. Oberst already has shared stages with R.E.M. and befriended Michael Stipe. A few weeks ago, he received a thrift-store jacket as a gift from another admirer, Bruce Springsteen, after con-cluding the Vote for Change arena tour.
As the release date nears for Bright Eyes' two new albums, the acoustic-flavored "I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning" and its more electronic, beat-driven companion, "Digital Ash in a Digital Urn" (both on Saddle Creek Records), tastemakers from all corners of the music industry and media are jumping at the opportunity to anoint Oberst the "new Dylan." The Los Angeles Times has already proclaimed "I'm Wide Awake" "the most absorbing singer-songwriter collection since Bob Dylan's `Time Out of Mind' eight years ago.
As premature as such accolades are, Oberst's cult of obsessive fans is expanding. Bright Eyes even briefly entered the same commercial galaxy as Sean "P. Diddy" Combs when the albums' debut singles were released two months ago. "Lua" and "Take It Easy (Love Nothing)" bowed in the top two slots on the Billboard Hot 100 Singles chart, the first one-two opening by an artist since Combs accomplished the feat in 1997.
Bright Eyes' previous album, "Lifted or the Story Is in the Soil, Keep Your Ear to the Ground," cracked the Billboard 200 and has sold nearly 200,000 copies since its 2002 release, a remarkable figure for an independent album that received virtually no commercial radio or video airplay. It made Oberst and Bright Eyes the icons of the flourishing Lincoln, Neb., scene, something of a self-contained industry with its own label (Saddle Creek), in-house producer (Bright Eyes' Mike Mogis) and recording studio (Mogis' Presto). Saddle Creek's stable of acclaimed indie bands includes Cursive, the Faint and Oberst's side project, Desparecidos.
Oberst, who brings Bright Eyes to the Riviera on Monday, is aware of the hype. But he'd rather concentrate on writing songs. Ask him to assess his recordings, and he'll say that he isn't completely satisfied with any of them.
"I remember listening to Fugazi when I was about 13, and realizing that a song could mean something more than just `la-la-la,'" says Oberst, speaking in a quiet, halting voice that's the antithesis of rock-star cool. "Do I ever match that standard? I don't know if I ever do. I have to feel a certain way about a song before I'll release it or perform it, but I never really thought, `This is the one! I've got a hit on my hands!' It's more like, I need to keep writing more songs and not judge them.
"For me, the songs are never done. They change every time I play them, or sometimes I wear out on them. There is no `right' version of one of my songs, ever."
Though Oberst has churned out a lot of songs and developed a devoted following that dotes on his every self-absorbed word, he has yet to make a classic album on par with the great songwriters to whom he's routinely compared (everyone from Townes Van Zandt to Beck). His tremulous voice and stream-of-consciousness lyrics affirm his soul-baring authenticity to his followers but sound overwrought and whiny to his detractors. The Riverfront Times, a St. Louis counterculture weekly, recently named him one of the "10 most hated men in rock": "Who wants to hear sad, sad songs about the day-to-day pathos of well-to-do suburban white kids?" it mocked.
A new direction
But "I'm Wide Awake" and "Digital Ash" should give the skeptics pause. The country-folk melodies on the former are among his sparsest and most direct, and include vocal contributions from country queen Emmylou Harris and My Morning Jacket singer Jim James, a former skeptic who was won over by Oberst's passion and sincerity.
"I didn't really get his music" until they played a show together two years ago, James says. "But that night at the acoustic show, it was very quiet and I really listened and heard some of the things he was saying. He taught me the value of a good lyric, a good phrase, and a clever way of saying something that all of us think but never think to voice. . . . He is a cut above most of his peers in creating vivid visual images."
"Digital Ash" envelops those images in arrangements that are by turns dusky, daring and grand. The two releases are easily the most disciplined albums of Oberst's career, framing his fervor rather than letting it run wild. Put the best of the two together and Oberst would have his defining statement. But as they are, the albums provide ample insight into a precociously talented artist who keeps testing his boundaries at a prolific rate, as if he were racing time to release every lyric, melody and sound he hears in his head.
Oberst is said to have written a song nearly every day since he acquired his first guitar, when he was about 10. "I didn't learn scales or Metallica riffs, and I didn't really learn a lot of cover songs either," he says. "I was immediately interested in putting words together and singing. After I learned a couple of chords, I started making up [stuff]."
Born the youngest of three sons in Omaha to a middle-class family, he was hanging out with an older crowd of aspiring musicians at the University of Nebraska campus in nearby Lincoln before he was even in high school.
"I thought it was so strange to see this 11-year-old kid with long hair coming around playing his guitar," says his future Bright Eyes collaborator Mike Mogis, 30. "They were intelligent songs, even back then. None of us could believe it."
As a class project, Mogis and another dorm buddy, Robb Nansel, created Saddle Creek Records. It soon became an outlet for their friends' music, including Oberst's. The young songwriter had been piling up homemade cassettes of his songs while fronting the indie-pop band Commander Venus. Once he heard those solo performances, Mogis was hooked. He dragged his recording gear over to the house of Oberst's parents, set up in the laundry room, and let the kid roll. "I wanted to preserve the casualness, the informality, the sincerity, but make sure it was more sonically and musically pleasing," he says.
Mogis and Oberst have been joined at the hip musically ever since, surrounded by a constantly rotating cast of musicians drawn from their large pool of friends in Lincoln. Bright Eyes tours habitually pile more than a dozen musicians into a bus, and sell out clubs and theaters across the country. No two touring lineups have ever been alike, and Oberst's songs have been fleshed out with everything from string sections to kazoos.
"We don't care about being perfect, it's more important to keep things fresh," says Mogis of the rotating lineups. He applies the same principle when recording Oberst. "A lot of things today are cut and pasted into perfection, but where's the expressiveness? Conor comes from the same school of thought: How to immediately convey a thought or feeling."
Oberst's obsession with immediacy runs pretty deep. He's averse to repeating hooks or choruses, instead preferring to string verses together until the songs are pushing 10 minutes. He rarely writes anything down, so that the songs feel new every time he steps to the microphone. He aims to capture that moment when "the whole fog of the day hasn't fully sunk into the brain, that spot between being asleep and being awake." The dreamlike cadences rise and fall between whispers and screams, and the instruments crest and tumble with him.
Amid that off-the-cuff spirit, larger themes begin to emerge. "Digital Ash" is preoccupied with mortality and the passage of time, "Wide Awake" with travel and transition.
"Almost every record we've made, somebody has called it a concept record," Oberst says. "I've always found that strange because to me all records should be concept records. We've always been into songs that blend into one another and weird interludes connecting songs and having recurring themes."
That sense of cohesiveness is aided by Mogis' production. Acoustic instruments and peddle-steel guitar cast "Wide Awake" in country-folk hews that encompass raw protest ballads ("Landlocked Blues"), raucous train songs ("Another Travelin' Song") and Holy Roller spirituals ("Road to Joy"). "Digital Ash" flirts with Caribbean-flavored beats ("Arc of Time"), orchestral strings ("I Believe in Symmetry") and disembodied choirs ("Gold Mine Gutted").
Oberst still lives out too many melodramas in his lyrics ("Let the poet cry himself to sleep"), but his music has rarely been more focused or inclusive. He steps into the world, and though he doesn't always like what he sees ("I read the body count out of the paper/And now it's written all over my face"), his more outward looking music is a promising sign of greater accomplishments to come.
Mogis sounds like a proud older brother when he traces the growth of his young accomplice over the last decade. "His writing used to be very self-centered, but he's starting to delve into more universal topics and social issues that affect everybody," the producer says. "He basically used to sing about how depressed he was about girls, but anybody with a little older perspective wouldn't care. Now he's better able to articulate the world around him with poetic grace. It's a huge step, and that's carried over to the way he makes music.
"Before it was just about his voice and guitar. Now he thinks about how his song involves other people, other parts and instruments beyond what he's doing. He hears the whole thing now."
- - -
Double releases not always a success
Bright Eyes won't be the first band or artist to release two new albums simultaneously. The strategy has been employed in the past by artists ranging from Guns N' Roses to Paul Westerberg, with widely varying degrees of success.
Inevitably, artists who do release more than one album's worth of material at a time are wary of an instant backlash. "Can you imagine the [criticism] we would've gotten if we'd release two at once?" singer Thom Yorke said when asked why Radiohead released "Kid A" and its follow-up, "Amnesiac," several months apart in 2000-01, even though both were recorded at the same sessions.
Bruce Springsteen took a critical and commercial beating when he chose to release "Lucky Town" and "Human Touch" on the same day in 1992. Both albums quickly sank off the charts and remain the black marks in a career otherwise filled with savvy marketing moves. Guns N' Roses had much bigger commercial success with "Use Your Illusion I" and "II," released simultaneously in 1991, but the band broke up soon afterward.
Westerberg engineered a comeback with "Stereo" and "Mono" in 2002, pairing a solo acoustic album with a garage-rock outing. Westerberg said he didn't want to cram 70 minutes of music onto one CD, so he presented the discs separately but packaged them together.
In contrast, Bright Eyes' "I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning" and "Digital Ash in a Digital Urn" share only a release date. They will be sold separately, and singer Conor Oberst will lead separate tours with different lineups to focus on each album.
"The only reason they're being released on the same day is more a matter of practicality," Oberst says. "We recorded the folk record last February because I had been playing many of those songs for a while. But we'd always talked about making a more rhythm-intensive record with a more experimental approach. At first the idea was to take the best of both approaches and make it into one album, but within a few weeks of working on the `Digital' record it became pretty obvious that it was a different approach that held together on its own.
"Then we had another choice: Do we put out the folk record and keep working on the `Digital' album? We felt we might get trapped in the same interview-tour cycle after the folk album came out, and leave this other project undone for a long time. That didn't seem appealing, so we decided to kill two birds with one stone."
Oberst says his longtime hometown label, Saddle Creek Records, didn't put up much of a fight. "We're fortunate to have a record label run by friends who leave the final decisions up to us," he says. "We thought about what it might mean, that people might be confused, or buy one album instead of another, or none at all. But in the end, sales aren't very high on the priority list of what we're doing. It's more about being able to express ourselves in a way that feels right. And this feels right to us now."
LP / CD / MP3
LP / CD / Cassette / MP3
LP / CD / Cassette / MP3
LP / CD / Cassette / MP3